Xuenou > Popular > American Horror Stories S2 Finally Explains Spalding's Coven Origins
American Horror Stories S2 Finally Explains Spalding's Coven Origins
American Horror Stories' season 2 episode 'Dollhouse' returns to AHS: Coven to tell the origin story of Miss Robichaux Academy's mute butler Spalding.

American Horror Stories S2 Finally Explains Spalding's Coven Origins

WARNING! This post contains SPOILERS for American Horror Stories season 2, episode 1!

The American Horror Stories season 2 episode “Dollhouse” tells the previously untold origin story of the American Horror Story: Coven character Spalding. Serving as a spinoff to American Horror Story, FX on Hulu’s American Horror Stories tells a new terrifying tale every episode as opposed to every season. While American Horror Stories season 1 brought back characters from AHS: Murder House, season 2 is reviving at least one mysterious narrative from AHS: Coven.

Set in 1961 Mississippi, “Dollhouse” follows Coby (Kristine Froseth) after she is kidnapped during a job interview with doll maker Mr. Van Wirt (Denis O’Hare). Coby is brought back to Van Wirt’s large estate, where he has created a life-size dollhouse for the women he kidnaps to perform “tests.” While forcing the women to dress up as dolls, Coby and the other women must take part in different housekeeping tasks; if they fail, they’re pushed down a well to their deaths, but if they “win,” they become the new mother to Van Wirt’s son, Otis. After “winning” the contest, American Horror Stories season 2, episode 1’s ending sees the magically-powered Coby and Otis escape with the help of two witches from Miss Robichaux’s Academy.

The true connection to American Horror Story: Coven is revealed in the ending of “Dollhouse” when Coby tells Otis he must go by a new name, choosing his middle name, “Spalding.” While it was already suspected that American Horror Stories’ season 2 episode would connect to Coven due to the dollhouse obsessions, Denis O’Hare’s casting, and Coby’s magical powers, “Dollhouse” established itself as an origin story by revealing Otis was, in fact, Coven’s butler character Spalding. Much of Spalding’s background had been a mystery in AHS: Coven, with the Miss Robichaux’s Academy butler being notable for his cut-out tongue, unrequited love for Fiona, and unsettling obsession with dolls. Nearly a decade after Coven debuted, American Horror Stories’ “Dollhouse” character, Otis, reveals an even more terrifying backstory for Spalding.

How American Horror Stories Retcons Spalding’s Coven Role

While American Horror Stories’ season 2 episode gave intriguing context for mysteries about Spalding’s origins, the spinoff also retconned a few details from his past that were revealed in AHS: Coven. Alongside explaining that his real name is Otis Van Wirt, with Spalding being his middle name, American Horror Stories’ “Dollhouse” changed his true connection to Miss Robichaux’s Academy. In American Horror Story: Coven, Denis O’Hare’s Spalding explained that he had come from a family line of servants for the witches, having lived at Miss Robichaux’s Academy all his life. However, AHS: Coven retcons this fact to confirm that Spalding arrived when he was already a child, with Coby telling him to lie in order to cover up his past.

American Horror Stories season 2, episode 1 also retcons Spalding’s Coven backstory in regard to his collection of “living dolls.” Toward the end of American Horror Story: Coven, Spalding takes the baby that was meant to be sacrificed to Papa Legba, declaring it his first living doll (as Madison was already dead when he used her as a doll). American Horror Stories’ “Dollhouse” then reveals that this was another lie, as Spalding had several “living dolls” during his childhood when his father kidnapped women. Although American Horror Stories season 2 makes Spalding’s AHS: Coven backstory more unsettling, it also explains that much of his odd obsessions and behaviors were ingrained by his father.