The Pale Blue Eye Review
With the whodunnit enjoying a comeback via the likes of Glass Onion, See How They Run and Death On The Nile, the time's surely ripe for a murder-mystery movie which involves the genre's very inventor. However, neither Louis Bayard’s original 2006 novel The Pale Blue Eye nor this moody adaptation by Scott Cooper (Crazy Heart, Hostiles) go as far as to make Edgar Allan Poe the lead detective. More intriguingly, he is the recruited sidekick: part assistant, part observer, part possible suspect.
This gives Cooper (as it did Bayard) the opportunity to dot Poe-ish Easter eggs around the narrative, especially given we meet him as a young man (played by one-time Dudley Dursley, Harry Melling) who is bound to be moulded by the macabre events that occur during his time at West Point. However, the focus is more on Christian Bale as Augustus Landor: a dour fellow with a robust reputation as a New York City constable, now retired and a West Point local. He is prone to a tipple, a recent widower, and has a missing daughter, all of which make his mood darker and frostier than his wintry, Gothic surroundings.
The climax is as bloody as it is bloody ridiculous.
This is where the initial promise of The Pale Blue Eye starts to leak away. Bale has done great work with Cooper before, in Out Of The Furnace and Hostiles, but Landor just isn’t a very interesting protagonist. Unlike Benoit Blanc or the Branagh-portrayed Poirot, he has no flair, no charm, no engaging quirks or investigative style. He scowls, grumbles and rubs his starchy employers (stalwart but misplaced Brits Timothy Spall and Simon McBurney) the wrong way. A lack of tact can’t be mistaken for a personality.
There is considerable compensation in the shape of Melling, who brings some much-needed colour; he even sports an outrageous Benoit Blanc-ish Kentucky-fried accent (though Poe was from Boston). After showing promise in The Ballad Of Buster Scruggs and The Devil All The Time, this is Melling’s true breakthrough, as he pulls off the tricky, square-circling act of making the young Poe as attractive as he is peculiar, as likeable as he is arrogant.
But even he can’t hold the film together as the story eventually veers into hokey occult territory, with a bonneted, buck-toothed Gillian Anderson seemingly parachuted in from a long-lost Coen brothers caper as a West Point brat’s unhinged Mommy. The climax is as bloody as it is bloody ridiculous, while the final reveal just doesn’t click; the ‘who’ in this whodunnit fails to convince in terms of the ‘why’ and the ‘how’. A careful rewatch might perhaps help, but it’s unlikely you’ll feel inspired to attempt one.
A handsome murder mystery with a neat literary twist and an impressive turn from Harry Melling, but which is overcast by the gloominess of its protagonist and the implausibility of its revelations.
Related Articles
Christian Bale Investigates A Brutal Murder In The Pale Blue Eye Trailer
Movies |
Related News & Content
-
Limit taxonomy terms added to a custom post type
Limit taxonomy terms added to a custom post type,I've created a Custom Post Type and a Custom Taxonomy. In WP Admin, how can I limit amount of taxonomy terms that are added to the custom post type? I want to add no more than one tag into the post. Tags: custom post types custom taxonomy limit stackexchange.com WordPress Development Stack Exchange -
Query top level custom post in taxonomy
Query top level custom post in taxonomy,This is my first post, I'm a bit stuck. I have a custom post (dan) and taxonomy (dnas), with hierarchical categories. I want to make a query resulting in posts at toplevel (hoofdcategorie01, Tags: stackexchange.com taxonomy WordPress Development Stack Exchange wp query -
Gutenberg: Restrict Top Level Blocks, But Not Child Blocks
Gutenberg: Restrict Top Level Blocks, But Not Child Blocks,Background I've created a custom top level "page section" block, to work with my existing theme. I've like to restrict top level blocks to ONLY that one block. However, I don't want to di... Tags: block editor stackexchange.com WordPress Development Stack Exchange -
How do I load styles into the block editor admin screen?
How do I load styles into the block editor admin screen?,The core file 'load-styles.php' generates css styles. Some of the styles interfere with the block editor. I would like to pass in my own style rules that override the styles generated by 'load-styl... Tags: block editor stackexchange.com WordPress Development Stack Exchange -
Installing WordPress in a subdirectory
Installing WordPress in a subdirectory,I am trying to install wordpress into a subdirectory of a website. I simply want to build the client's new site in this subdirectory, so a separate and new WP install in this subdirectory, and the... Tags: installation stackexchange.com WordPress Development Stack Exchange -
Custom theme and plugin updating
Custom theme and plugin updating,History: I'm working on a project for a client that involves building 27 unique websites that are built on wordpress. I say unique, because (for reasons that are not worth going into here) they ar... Tags: automatic updates plugin development stackexchange.com theme development WordPress Development Stack Exchange -
Rewrite nested urls for custom post type
Rewrite nested urls for custom post type,I have a problem with nested permalink. I have a structure of urls like that: Catalog -> Category -> Product My urls are: www.domain.com/catalogs (for archive catalog) www.domain.com/catal... Tags: custom post types stackexchange.com url rewriting WordPress Development Stack Exchange -
Ajax not working to insert, query and result data
Ajax not working to insert, query and result data,On my site, through a form I send/register same information in database, do a SELECT/query and return it! Return the last table saved in database, just that user just entered on the form (along wit... Tags: Ajax database functions plugin development stackexchange.com WordPress Development Stack Exchange -
Israel at war, day 204: Hamas airs video of Israeli hostages, one with U.S. citizenship
Israel at war, day 204: Hamas airs video of Israeli hostages, one with U.S. citizenship,Hamas Studying Israel's Response to Position on Cease-fire Talks Gaza Aid Shipments Resume From Cyprus IDF: Two Palestinians Killed After Firing on IDF Outpost in the West Bank Pro-Palestinian Protest Leader Banned From Columbia Campus Here's What You Need to Know 204 Days Into the War Tags: 2023 Israel Gaza War haaretz.com Israel News -
Carol Kirkwood stuns in figure-hugging dress amid BBC Breakfast technical chaos
Carol Kirkwood stuns in figure-hugging dress amid BBC Breakfast technical chaos,CAROL Kirkwood stunned in a figure-hugging dress amid a technical blunder. BBC Breakfast was flung into chaos this morning after a string of sound issues. However Carol, 61, was all smiles as she p… Tags: BBC BBC Breakfast BBC ONE Carol Kirkwood mirror.co.uk The Scottish Sun TV News TV UK daytime TV -
Families ‘to sue prison’ where loud inmates ‘terrorise kids’ with screaming
Families 'to sue prison' where loud inmates 'terrorise kids' with screaming,Residents living next door to a new prison who say their kids have to sleep wearing headphones and some leave during weekends due to the racket are threatening to sue the prison service Tags: mirror.co.uk Neighbours from hell prisons Scottish government The Mirror -
Doctor Strange’s Secret Wars Role May Be More Important Than You Thought – Looper
Doctor Strange's Secret Wars Role May Be More Important Than You Thought - Looper,According to entertainment leaker Alex Perez, Doctor Strange will find himself confronting his inner struggles as he headlines "Avengers: Secret Wars." Tags: Fiction Looper looper.com Marvel Cinematic Universe Science Star Wars The Universal Monsters franchise -
Choctaw artist Jeffrey Gibson confronts history at US pavilion as its first solo Indigenous artist
Choctaw artist Jeffrey Gibson confronts history at US pavilion as its first solo Indigenous artist,Jeffrey Gibson’s takeover of the U.S. pavilion for this year’s Venice Biennale contemporary art show is a celebration of color, pattern and craft Tags: 109377793 abcnews.go.com Article Entertainment General news Indigenous people Keycat Keytags Race and ethnicity U.S. News visual arts World news -
Mexican film wins top prize at Moscow International Film Festival while major studios boycott Russia
Mexican film wins top prize at Moscow International Film Festival while major studios boycott Russia,A Mexican film has won the top prize at the Moscow International Film Festival which took place as major Western studios boycott the Russian market and as Russia’s war in Ukraine grinds into its third year Tags: 109702159 abcnews.go.com Article Entertainment Fairs and festivals General news Keycat Keytags Movies Russia Ukraine war World news -
Tragedy Drove Alex Irish Away From Deep Ellum. The Music Brought Her Back.
Tragedy Drove Alex Irish Away From Deep Ellum. The Music Brought Her Back.,Dallas singer Alex Irish survived a shooting in Deep Ellum, and she's back with a vengeance with the EP Twisted Metal . Tags: dallas concerts dallas live music. dallas observer dallasobserver.com deep ellum concerts. dfw live music new artists. new bands new singers texas artists texas music -
The Irish Musicians of Dallas Get Ready for St. Patrick’s Day
The Irish Musicians of Dallas Get Ready for St. Patrick’s Day,The Irish bands of Dallas are for the biggest shows of the year on St. Patrick's Day. Tags: Dallas dallas observer dallasobserver.com irish Irish music Linda Relph Plunk Murray Sluggers Rule St. Patrick's Day -
Volumio's Motivo Streamer merges function and beauty in one device
Volumio's Motivo Streamer merges function and beauty in one device,Italian music streaming brand Volumio has introduced its Motivo Streamer, which it describes as "blending beautiful Italian craft with true audio | Trusted Reviews Tags: Hi Fi and Wireless Audio sound tech news trustedreviews trustedreviews.com TV and Audio Reviews volumio -
Hulu now officially folded into Disney+ for US bundle subscribers
Hulu now officially folded into Disney+ for US bundle subscribers,Guide to TVs, media streamers & monitors Tags: Flatpanels flatpanelshd.com news TV test streaming Smart picture quality pq 4K SD HD 1080p 720p FlatpanelsHD Flatpanels
Warning: file_get_contents(https://www.scienceradars.com/wp-output-content.php?pg=1&cat=&kw=&lvl=): Failed to open stream: HTTP request failed! HTTP/1.1 526 in /home/wwwroot/xuenou.com/wp-content/themes/chromenews/template-parts/content.php on line 169
Warning: file_get_contents(https://www.bayuexiang.com/wp-output-content.php?pg=1&cat=&kw=&lvl=): Failed to open stream: HTTP request failed! HTTP/1.1 526 in /home/wwwroot/xuenou.com/wp-content/themes/chromenews/template-parts/content.php on line 173
TrendRadars
The Most Interesting Articles, Mysteries and Discoveries