The problem with Blue is the Warmest Colour
The problem with Blue is the Warmest Colour
It’s hard to know for sure how Abdellatif Kechiche felt when, for the first time in the history of the Cannes Film Festival, the Palme D’or was awarded not just to him and his film, Blue is the Warmest Colour, but also to the two lead actresses, Léa Seydoux and Adèle Exarchopoulous. He was certainly quick to lash out at them when they criticised his harsh working methods, especially Seydoux who, in an op-ed for Rue89, he called an opportunist that was “fine-tune[ing] her image […] in endless calculated interviews”.
Kechiche complained that his film was “sullied”, but despite some criticism, most notably a blog post from Jul Muroh, the writer-artist of the source comics, the success of Blue was exceptional. It ended 2013 on countless best-of-the-year lists, coming third in both Cahier du Cinema and Sight & Sound’s collated lists. Now, ten years later, Kechiche’s career has truly been sullied, and even his most acclaimed film looks awfully different.
Blue’s graphic lesbian sex scenes, between Exarchopoulos’ Adèle and her first love, Seydoux’s older, confidently ‘out’ Emma, were certainly controversial at the time. Muroh called them “brutal and surgical”, like lesbian porn made for a straight audience. But few today would dare call them passionate or frank, as many reviews did. Their extreme length, leering camera and ignorance of the mechanics of sex have made them maybe the textbook example of the male gaze; they are a total fantasy shot with the tropes of realism.
Kechiche’s style is just a thin veil obscuring his desires from the audience and from himself. He seems to believe that holding a camera close enough to someone’s face – usually Exarchopoulos’ – for long enough (both in terms of the scenes and the shoot) will naturally capture something real, as if totally ignorant of the pressures and projections he brings. That which makes every scene, as J. Hoberman said of the sex scenes, “a menage a trois involving the actors and the camera”. The film isn’t told from Adèle’s perspective as it purports to be – it’s told from Kechiche’s.
His intrusions extend beyond the characters, as Seydoux and Exarchopoulos discussed in an interview with the Daily Beast. After shooting a hundred takes of Adèle and Emma crossing the street and exchanging their first glance, Seydoux couldn’t help but giggle, to which Kechiche “became so crazy that he picked up the little monitor [..] screaming ‘I can’t work under these conditions’”. Anyone taking his vision, for what is ultimately quite a silly scene of love at first sight, with anything less than total seriousness and submission is treated like an abuser. Unsurprisingly, when Exarchopoulos cut herself and was “bleeding everywhere and crying with her nose running”, Kechiche said she needed to do another take.
Seydoux temporarily stepped back from this interview in early 2014 when she told the Evening Standard “I love his cinema […] the way he treats us? So what!” This wasn’t an uncommon defence, the means are justified by the ends. But Kechiche undoubtedly damaged the performances, while there isn’t a moment where anyone is less than totally convincing, a character built only in close-up lacks context. They don’t exist outside of what happens to them, outside of what he does to them. More importantly though, some things can’t be justified by any performance, and Kechiche would cross that line in his follow-up: a trilogy of films that would destroy his career in a way that no new perspective on Blue ever could.
Mektoub, My Love was troubled from the start, with producers pulled out after learning that it was going to be split into three parts, and Kechiche had to sell his Palme to complete the first two: Canto Uno in 2017 and Intermezzo in 2019 (both of which played Cannes). In them all his worst tendencies are expanded: the sketchiness of Blue’s arc from first love to heartbreak turns to total plotlessness, the ogling of women becomes the entire point, and the sex scenes not only grow longer, but are shot unsimulated rather than with the use of prosthetic genitals. The lead actors, Ophélie Bau and Shaïn Boumédine, were uncomfortable with this, but, to quote an anonymous report published in Midi Libre in 2019, “by the way of insistence, and over time and with alcohol being regularly consumed, [Kechiche] managed to get what he wanted.”
It’s hard to argue that there aren’t great directors who see themselves in the lineage of the great male artist that sits at a typewriter (or camera) and bleeds, that bares his soul on screen and on set. But Kechiche shows this idea, stripped of pretences and other merit, for what it really is: an excuse to enact power, often in a gendered way, torturing a performance from an actress as if she was incapable of doing it herself. Kechiche mockingly, maliciously flaunts this in one of Blue’s first scenes, when an off-screen voice, a male teacher, directs one of his female students to read aloud this passage: “I am a woman and I tell my story”.
Today, the third Mektoub film remains in limbo and Intermezzo hasn’t received a wide release since its first two screenings at Cannes. It’s tempting to think that this story is one of justice that illustrates how far we’ve come in the last ten years. This year, when reports came out about harassment by the director and inappropriate behaviour by the crew on the set of Catherine Corsini’s Le Retour, Cannes pulled it from the competition spot it was already promised. As was also reported in Variety, Corsini added a masturbation scene featuring the fifteen year old lead actress to the script and filmed it without informing the government body that legislates underage performers, causing some of the film’s funding from the CNC, France’s national film board, to be revoked.
But the president of the CNC, Dominique Boutonnat, has held his position even while being investigated for sexual assault. And before Corsini and her producer responded, denying any claims of abuse and including a statement from Gohourou, but admitting that they should have reported the aforementioned scene, her film was added back to the official selection. In less than two weeks the whole situation was resolved, all due diligence had apparently been done.
There seemed little anxiety in announcing the festival’s opening film, Jeanne du Barry, the first to star Johnny Depp since his pisive trial against Amber Heard which, in and of itself, made the wins of MeToo feel precarious. To me, it felt like the end of something. If a woman is less than a perfect victim, Depp, his lawyers and countless TikToks told us, if she so much as raises her hand, she isn’t even complicit, she is the real abuser. The most prestigious film festival in the world seems to agree (and if you don’t, well, protests have been banned, I’m afraid).
Maybe Mektoub My Love’s final part is too sullied, but the only real difference between the series and Blue is the Warmest Colour is that the latter, to quote the speech Steven Speilberg gave when awarding it the Palme, “made all of us feel like we were privileged […] to be flies on the wall”. It created a convincing facsimile of prestige, like a scene in a gallery that framed the lurid sex scenes within the tradition of nude painting, which obscured, or for some even justified, Kechiche’s cruelty and desire.
Published 26 May 2023