8 Actors Who Couldn’t Stand The Remakes Of Their Films Or TV Shows, And 6 Who Loved Them
When a new remake, reboot, or sequel comes out, we usually hear immediately from fans and critics comparing it to the original source material. But what about the people who were actually involved in making the originals? Well, here are 14 actors who had something to say about their movie or TV show getting revived.
1. In 2005, Tim Burton released his adaptation of the 1964 Roald Dahl novel Charlie and the Chocolate Factory starring Johnny Depp. Though not a remake of 1971’s Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory starring Gene Wilder, it’s hard not to compare the two films.
Before the ’05 version’s release, Wilder called the movie a cash grab, and years later, in 2013, he said of Burton’s film, “I think it’s an insult. To do that with Johnny Depp, who I think is a good actor and I like him, but I don’t care for that director. He’s a talented man, but I don’t care for him for doing stuff like he did.”
Liu voiced her support for the Barrymore-produced reboot, saying, “To me, I think it’s very exciting. It’s like Sherlock Holmes…it is something that people keep coming back to, and they’re drawn to. That’s something that needs to be explored, and if it needs to be explored on all different levels, then it should be.”
3. In 2017, Universal released The Mummy starring Tom Cruise, an attempt at rebooting the late ’90s early ’00s Brendan Fraser-led franchise (the first installment of which is, in fact, a remake of a 1932 film of the same name).
Universal/Courtesy Everett Collection, Photo Credit: Chiabella James
When Cruise’s movie famously flopped, Fraser gave insight into why he thought the new film just didn’t work. He said, “It is hard to make that movie. The ingredient that we had going for our Mummy, which I didn’t see in that film, was fun. That was what was lacking in that incarnation. It was too much of a straight-ahead horror movie. The Mummy should be a thrill ride, but not terrifying and scary…I know how difficult it is to pull it off. I tried to do it three times.”
4. In 2017, Patty Jenkins’ Wonder Woman was released, starring Gal Gadot. The role was famously played by Lynda Carter in the late ’70s TV show of the same name.
Courtesy Everett Collection, Clay Enos / ©Warner Bros / courtesy Everett Collection / Everett Collection
After Titanic director James Cameron called the 2017 version of Wonder Woman “a step backwards” for women, Carter stepped in to defend the movie. She addressed Cameron on Facebook, stating, “You poor soul. Perhaps you do not understand the character. I most certainly do. Like all women — we are more than the sum of our parts. Your thuggish jabs at a brilliant director, Patty Jenkins, are ill-advised. This movie was spot on. Gal Gadot was great. I know, Mr. Cameron — because I have embodied this character for more than 40 years. So — STOP IT.”
5. In 2010, a remake of the 1984 slasher A Nightmare on Elm Street was released.
New Line Cinema / ©New Line Cinema/Courtesy Everett Collection, Warner Bros / ©Warner Bros/Courtesy Everett Collection
The new, and much darker version of the film was critically panned. Robert Englund, who played Freddy Krueger in the original movie (and all the sequels), called the remake “a little cold” and said that the “‘realist’ burn make-up…took a lot of the strength away from the character.” He also cited an issue with the film’s beginning, saying that since “we weren’t really given time to see the kids when they were normal, before they were frantic and haunted by Freddy,” it “made it harder to connect with them, harder to care what happened to them.”
6. The Will Smith-led sitcom, The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, ran from 1990-1996. In 2022, the show was reimagined as Bel-Air, a drama series with a much more serious tone.
Tatyana Ali, who played Ashley in The Fresh Prince, praised the series. She said, “I think it’s brilliant. Flipping it and making it a drama is so dope. I think that’s part of this lasting power of the sitcom — it was based in real stuff.”
7. In 1996, Eddie Murphy starred in a remake of The Nutty Professor. Jerry Lewis wrote, directed, and starred in the original, which was released in 1963.
Cbs Photo Archive / CBS via Getty Images, Universal Pictures
Although Lewis praised Murphy, calling him “one of the five funniest men in the world,” he had an issue with the remake’s big fart scene. “When he had to do fart jokes, he lost me.” Lewis, who produced the film, added that he even gave the editor an ultimatum: get rid of the farts or they’d lose him “on a creative level.” Overall, Lewis said, “What I did was perfect. And all you’re going to do is diminish that perfection by letting someone else do it.”
And for anyone wondering, the farts stayed.
8. In one of her first-ever movies, Drew Barrymore played the lead character Charlie McGee in the 1984 movie Firestarter. In 2022, the movie was remade starring Ryan Kiera Armstrong.
Universal/Courtesy Everett Collection
When Armstrong appeared on The Drew Barrymore Show, Barrymore told her, through tears, “I watched the movie. It’s so good. You’re so good in it.” She also told Armstrong how grateful she was to be able to share the role of Charlie McGee with her.
9. In 2018, the fourth iteration of A Star Is Born was released, starring Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper. The last version of the film to come out prior to the Lady Gaga one was released in 1976 and starred Barbra Streisand and Kris Kristofferson.
Streisand was disappointed with the 2018 remake, calling it the “wrong idea” and criticizing its supposed lack of originality. She had originally heard that the film was to star Beyoncé and Will Smith, which she thought was an “interesting” idea. “Really make it different again, different kind of music, integrated actors. I thought that was a great idea.” However, when the Gaga/Cooper version was released, she said, “I was surprised when I saw how alike it was to the version that I did in 1976.”
10. Adam West played Batman in the 1960s live-action TV series and the 1966 film Batman: The Movie. From 1989 to 1997, actors Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer, and George Clooney took their turns playing the role. Then in 2005, Christopher Nolan cast Christian Bale as the lead in what would be the first installment in his Dark Knight Trilogy.
20th Century Fox Film Corp./Courtesy Everett Collection, Warner Bros./Courtesy Everett Collection
In 2013, when asked about other actors who’ve played Batman, West said that at first, he felt like the character belonged to him but “quickly realized that they were doing their thing.” He specifically mentioned Christian Bale and called him “marvelous in The Dark Knight.”
11. Melissa Joan Hart played Sabrina in the 1996 TV movie Sabrina the Teenage Witch based on the Archie Comics series, and then a few months later, reprised the role in a sitcom of the same name, which ran until 2003. In 2018, Netflix released Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, a series that was based on a separate Archie series with a much darker tone.
George Lange / ©Viacom Prod. / Courtesy: Everett Collection, Diyah Pera / ©Netflix / Courtesy Everett Collection